Defending College Heights is an investigation into the murder of a U.S. Army recruiter within a tumultuous and corrupt college community.
The body of U.S Army captain and recruiting commander Kevin Callahan is found in a guardhouse at Hudson Technical University, a small private engineering school located in College Heights. A message left on Callahan's t-shirt reads, "No more lies." The news media and pro-military and anti-war activists believe the murder was committed in opposition to unethical army recruiting.
Angered by the biased media coverage, Callahan's uncle, Philadelphia area urban planner Jack Donnelly, comes to College Heights determined to become involved in the murder investigation. Fearing that Jack's involvement may embarrass the university but desperately needing his help to save her school, Hudson Tech president Martina Tiernan asks him to become special assistant for campus planning.
While Jack believes that Tiernan is trying to buy his silence, he reluctantly comes aboard. He learns that the murder is the lynchpin to a larger scheme that could close Hudson Tech’s doors for good.
Just 3 months after returning from his second tour in Iraq and taking on his new role as a recruiting commander in College Heights, Kevin Callahan is brutally stabbed to death and the words “No more lies” are written on his shirt. The police have few leads and the Army is staying out of the investigation so Kevin’s uncle, Jack Donnelly, heads out to College Heights to check things out for himself. He takes a job at Hudson Tech University, where Kevin’s body was found, and discovers there may be more to this crime than meets the eye. Was Kevin killed by someone opposed to the war or is does it go deeper? Jack is determined to find out and will do whatever it takes to find those responsible.
“Defending College Heights” is more than a murder mystery. Author Stuart Nachbar has written a story that is timely, yet objective. He takes a controversial subject, the war in Iraq and military recruiting, and weaves it into the story in a way that makes the reader think but doesn’t shove any particular view in the reader’s face. Besides the politics involved in the war, the author also gets into university politics and we see some similarities between the two worlds that are sometimes shocking and always interesting. It is a nice compare/contrast that I haven’t really seen before.
Mr. Nachbar also takes the time to develop the characters so they are not only interesting but very real. My only issue with the characters was the inclusion of Kevin’s brother, Kyle. Aside from showing a contrast between the brothers, I saw no purpose for the character. Every time Kyle was around I saw a side of Jack that I don’t think was necessary and really had a hard time liking Jack as much as I should have, considering he is the main character of the story.
All in all, I thought Defending College Heights was a really good mystery that kept me guessing until the end. I also liked the fact that the author took some time after the big reveal to wrap up the sub-plots. Many authors get so caught up in the climax of the story that they forget to tie up the loose ends and I really appreciated the effort the author took to make sure that did not happen in this novel. I would definitely recommend this book to mystery fans and I look forward to Stuart Nachbar’s future writings.